Social and Legal Studios
ISSN 2617-4162
e-ISSN 2617-4170
Publisher: Lviv State University of Internal Affairs
Abstract
The relevance of this study lies in the fact that the European Court plays a considerable role in protecting the rights and freedoms of citizens, and the judgements delivered by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) reflect the interaction of Ukrainian jurisdiction with European human rights norms and standards, which is crucial in the context of strengthening democratic principles and the rule of law in Ukraine. The purpose of this study was to examine the impact of judgements of the International Court of Human Rights on the structure and content of Ukrainian legislation. The following methods were used in the study: historical, hermeneutical, statistical, and comparative analysis. The study showed the impact of the decisions of the international court that guarantees the observance of individual freedoms on the development and transformation of the Ukrainian legal space. The study analysed how Ukrainian courts react to the ECHR judgements. It was found that these decisions are often used as a basis for improving legislation and law enforcement practice in Ukraine. However, there are also cases of non-compliance with ECHR judgements, which indicates the need to further strengthen the mechanisms of influence of international law on internal legislation of the country. The study examined particular cases where the ECHR judgements helped to defend the rights of Ukrainian citizens before internal judicial authorities or state institutions, which demonstrates the important role of the European Court in guaranteeing the protection of human rights in Ukraine. These decisions not only point out problems and gaps in national legislation, but also contribute to improving law enforcement and protecting citizens’ rights. The practical significance of this study lies in the fact that it will improve the practice of enforcement of the European Court’s judgements in the country, and the analysis of such judgements may also serve as a basis for developing mechanisms for protecting the rights of citizens in the Ukrainian judicial process
Keywords: international standards; convention; law; precedent; international agreements; justice
Suggested citation
[1] Akhmetova, A. (2023). Open coordination method as a European integration and governance mechanism. European Chronicle, 8(4), 26-35. doi: 10.59430/euch/4.2023.26.
[2] Bobić, A. (2020). Constructive versus destructive conflict: Taking stock of the recent constitutional jurisprudence in the EU. Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies, 22, 60-84. doi: 10.1017/cel.2020.9.
[3] Burchardt, D. (2020). Backlash against the court of justice of the EU? The recent jurisprudence of the German constitutional court on EU fundamental rights as a standard of review. German Law Journal, 21(1). doi: 10.1017/glj.2020.16.
[4] Constitution of the Federal Republic of Germany. (1949, May). Retrieved from https://www.1000dokumente.de/?c=dokument_ de&dokument=0014_gru&object=translation&l=ru.
[5] Constitution of Ukraine. (1996, June). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/254%D0%BA/96-%D0%B2%D1%80#Text.
[6] Council of Europe Convention on Preventing and Combating Violence against Women and Domestic Violence. (2011, May). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/994_001-11#Text.
[7] Datsiuk, T., Kuznetsova, Z., & Nikolenko, K. (2022). Transformation of the human rights protection mechanism at the current stage. Academic Visions, 14. Retrieved from doi: 10.5281/zenodo.7431715.
[8] Decision of the European Court of Human Rights in Case No. 17496/19 “Levchuk v. Ukraine”. (2020, December). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/974_f92#Text.
[9] Decision of the European Court of Human Rights in Case No. 22251/08 “Bochan v. Ukraine”. (2015, February). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/974_a43#Text.
[10] Decision of the European Court of Human Rights in Case No. 75529/01 “Sürmeli v. Germany”. (2006, August). Retrieved from https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/rus#{%22itemid%22:[%22002-3291%22]}.
[11] Dufeniuk, O. (2021). The impact of the ECHR on the formation of the supranational and national paradigm of human rights (Ukrainian context). Ideology and Politics Journal, 17(1), 232-250. doi: 10.36169/2227-6068.2021.01.00011.
[12] Enforcement of judgements of the European Court of Human Rights. (2024). Retrieved from https://minjust.gov.ua/m/str_4324.
[13] European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. (1950, November). Retrieved from https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/convention_ukr.
[14] European Court of Human Rights. (2024a). Country profile: Ukraine. Retrieved from https://www.echr.coe.int/web/echr/d/ cp_ukraine_eng?p_l_back_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.echr.coe.int%2Fsearch.
[15] European Court of Human Rights. (2024b). Statistical reports. Retrieved from https://www.echr.coe.int/statistical-reports.
[16] Fichera, M., & Pollicino, O. (2019). The dialectics between constitutional identity and common constitutional traditions. Which language for cooperative constitutionalism in Europe? German Law Journal, 20(8), 1097-1118. doi: 10.1017/glj.2019.82.
[17] Haglund, J., & Welch, R.M. (2020). From litigation to rights: The case of the European Court of Human Rights. International Studies Quarterly, 65(1), 210-222. doi: 10.1093/isq/sqaa089.
[18] Helfer, L.R. (2021). Rethinking derogations from human rights treaties. American Journal of International Law, 115(1), 20-40. doi: 10.1017/ajil.2020.92.
[19] Jovičić, S. (2021). COVID-19 restrictions on human rights in the light of the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights. ERA Forum, 21, 545-560. doi: 10.1007/s12027-020-00630-w.
[20] Kamenchuk, T.O. (2023). Protection of human rights, interaction between Ukraine and the European Union. In Materials of the III all-Ukrainian scientific conference “Actual discourses of variety art: Traditions and European integration” (pp. 391-396). Kyiv: Kyiv National University of Culture and Arts.
[21] Kapelańska-Pręgowska, J. (2021). The scales of the European court of human rights. Health and Human Rights Journal, 23(2), 213-224.
[22] Khablo, O., & Svoboda, I. (2024). International standards for the application of the presumption of innocence in criminal proceedings. Scientific Journal of the National Academy of Internal Affairs, 29(1), 55-65. doi: 10.56215/naia-herald/1.2024.55.
[23] Kitsak, T.M., & Lylyk, M.V. (2023). Institutional support of intercultural communication in Ukraine in the context of implementation of its European integration vector. Democratic Governance, 1(31), 52-62. doi: 10.23939/dg2023.01.05.
[24] Kubarieva, O. (2023). Judicial proceedings within a reasonable time: European experience and Ukrainian realities. Law Journal of the National Academy of Internal Affairs, 13(4), 31-39. doi: 10.56215/naia-chasopis/4.2023.31.
[25] Küpper, H. (2011). The decisions of the European Court of human rights and their implementation in Germany. ICL Journal, 5(2), 200-210. doi: 10.1515/icl-2011-0207.
[26] Law of Ukraine No. 1402-VIII “On the Judiciary and the Status of Judges”. (2016, June). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada. gov.ua/laws/show/1402-19#Text.
[27] Law of Ukraine No. 1906-IV “On International Treaties of Ukraine”. (2004, June). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1906-15#Text.
[28] Law of Ukraine No. 3477-IV “On the Execution of Judgments and Application of the Case Law of the European Court of Human Rights”. (2006, February). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3477-15#Text.
[29] Madsen, M.R, Mayoral, J.A, Strezhnev, A., & Voeten, E. (2022). Sovereignty, substance, and public support for European Courts’ human rights rulings. American Political Science Review, 116(2), 419-438. doi: 10.1017/S0003055421001143.
[30] Medvedeva, M., Vols, M., & Wieling, M. (2020). Using machine learning to predict decisions of the European Court of Human Rights. Artificial Intelligence and Law, 28, 237-266. doi: 10.1007/s10506-019-09255-y.
[31] Milasiute, V. (2022). Interpretation of the right to an effective remedy in freedom of expression cases in the light of the rule of law principle. Archives of Philosophy of Law and Social Philosophy, 2(31), 7-21. doi: 10.36280/AFPiFS.2022.2.7.
[32] Nalin, E. (2023). Conflicts and dialogue between national constitutional systems and international law. In Encyclopedia of contemporary constitutionalism (pp. 1-11). Cham: Springer. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-31739-7_204-1.
[33] Petersen, N., & Patrick, W. (2022). The primacy of EU law and the Polish constitutional law judgment, study requested by the European parliament’s committee on civil liberties. Brussels: European Union.
[34] Ploszka, A. (2023). It never rains but it pours. The Polish constitutional tribunal declares the European Convention on Human Rights unconstitutional. Hague Journal on the Rule of Law, 15, 51-74. doi: 10.1007/s40803-022-00174-w.
[35] Podszun, R., & Overhoff, N. (2023). Beyond ECN directive – empirical study mapping judicial review of national competition law decisions – national report: Germany. SSRN. doi: 10.2139/ssrn.4384839.
[36] Pylypenko, D., & Spahija, D. (2023). Historical significance of Germany, France and Belgium in the creation of the European Union. Foreign Affairs, 33(1), 8-15. doi: 10.46493/2663-2675.33(1).2023.8-15.
[37] Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of Ukraine No. 1 “On Judicial Practice in Cases on Protection of Dignity and Honour of an Individual and Business Reputation of an Individual and Legal Entity”. (2009, February). Retrieved from https://www. viaduk.net/clients/vs.nsf/81b1cba59140111fc2256bf7004f9cd3/6cc3c5489fa411cec2257578003002d9?OpenDocument.
[38] Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of Ukraine No. 14 “On Judgment in a Civil Case”. (2009, December). Retrieved from https://zakononline.com.ua/documents/show/312521 312586.
[39] Schmahl, S. (2022). The European Court of Human Rights – can there be too much success? A comment. Journal of Human Rights Practice, 14(1), 191-203. doi: 10.1093/jhuman/huac024.
[40] Shulga, A., Perederii, O., & Hryhorenko, Y. (2023). Factors of forming and transformation of law and order of European Union: Theoretical legal aspect. Bulletin of Mariupol State University, 23-24, 69-75. doi: 10.34079/2226-3047-2023-13-25-69-75.
[41] Sieper, M. (2022). Between parental responsibility and state guardianship: Child endangerment as reflected in the case law of the Federal Constitutional Court and the European Court of Human Rights. In Institutional and professional approaches to child protection (pp. 169-200). Wiesbaden: Springer. doi: 10.1007/978-3-658-35097-0_9.
[42] Skuban-Eiseler, T, Orzechowski, M., & Steger, F. (2023). Access to healthcare for disabled individuals: An analysis of judgments of the European Court of Human Rights from an ethical perspective. Frontiers in Public Health, 10, article number 1015401. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.1015401.
[43] Spano, R. (2021). The rule of law as a lodestar of the European convention on human rights: The Strasbourg court and the Independence of the judiciary. European Law Journal, 27(1-3), 211-227. doi: 10.1111/eulj.12377.
[44] Tengilimoǧlu, D., & Pentassuglia, G. (2023). Legislation and practice of observing of human rights in Turkey in terms of European integration processes in the country. European Chronicle, 8(2), 38-46. doi: 10.59430/euch/2.2023.38.
[45] Tomuschat, C. (2010). The effects of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights according to the German Constitutional Court. German Law Journal, 11(5), 513-526. doi: 10.1017/S2071832200018678.
[46] Vasylenko, M.E. (2023). The principles of justice and reasonable period in commercial procedure: The impact of the provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights and the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights on their implementation. Scientific Bulletin of Uzhhorod National University, 79, 260-265. doi: 10.24144/2307-3322.2023.79.1.44.
[47] Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. (1969, May). Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/995_118#Text.
[48] Walther, M. (2019). Fundamental rights united in diversity. Retrieved from https://verfassungsblog.de/in-vielfalt-geeinte-grundrechte/.
[49] Yara, O., Golovko, L., Kapplová, O., Medvedska, V., & Funta, R. (2023). Legal regulation of the protection of women from domestic violence in Western Europe. Law. Human. Environment, 14(4), 79-91. doi: 10.31548/law/4.2023.79.